Thoughts On Free Will - Part 1

Free to Choose but Not Freed From Consequences of Your Choice

Do we have a will? Yes we can make choices. We can choose to love or to hate. We can even choose to reject God.

Do we have a free will? In a sense yes, but it is limited free will.

Well, what is really free will? 

Wills are only free if freed from consequences. Hence there is really no such thing as free will, until we eliminate all consequences from choice.

Adam knows a thing or two about that.

Hmmm.... One can object and say “Free will does not mean that. It means to do as you please or else the idea of love would become null & void. One needs free will in order to love or we would just be robots obeying all God says to do. We are obviously not.”

No one is challenging not being free to love. But this notion that somehow if you are not able to do as you please (i.e. free will), it makes love null and void is erroneous. And no we are not speaking about us being made as robots to serve God.

On one hand, yes you are free to choose period. But that freedom gets adjusted by the consequences of your choice. It gives input to whether it was the right choice or not. That is key.  This is the difference between freedom and liberty.

The consequences are a feedback loop to the accuracy of the last choice and it gives you something to consider for the next choice. Each consequence either brings you life, or death. This accountability brings an overt limitation to the next choice.

So everytime you choose, the consequential feedback is life or death. If one wants to keep choosing towards death, then yes, you are free to choose death.

True freedom comes when your choices lead to life.



God Is Over and Works In Spite of Free Will

Romans 9:6-24 introduces the notion of Eminent Domain "So then it depends not on human will or exertion, but on God, who has mercy"

We have freedom to choose, but only God has Eminent Domain where he can step in at anytime.

Let’s look at this another way. Has God ever stepped in, in spite of your free will in any way? Absolutely. 

For example, God by His grace can create the circumstances around you to cause you to change his mind about Him and accept Him as your Savior. Does that make your acceptance of Him null and void?

What about in an extreme case, (but it takes only one case to disprove this notion that if free will does not mean to do as you please, it makes love null and void), when God orchestrated the circumstances around Paul's conversion, by blinding him? Does this lessen Paul’s conversion? Does this lesson Paul’s love for God?

Being free to choose does not mean free from consequences of that choice.

At the same time, having the ability to freely choose does not limit God to orchestrate circumstances and events to have you change your mind or to judge you and cause you to repent.



He did it all the time to Israel when he states that He kicked them out of the land as a consequence of their choice in order to repent. How free is that? Yet paradoxically it was free.

God does this to each one who comes to Him. He divinely orchestrates the events for you to change your mind about Him. When you don't, He can judge or discipline you to change your mind again. His goodness in this regard also leads to repentance.

Any time someone says this or that denies free choice, I doubt they really extrapolate logically what they are saying.

Home associations, TSA, the police, local town and planning, denies free choice (sometimes for good reason) but we don't complain.


To have your will truly free is to freely decide to align your preferences with the One who can free you from, orchestrate and determine all consequences of your actions. This is to be truly free.

True freedom comes when your choices lead to life. This is called Liberty.

This Note:
Next Notes:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Harpazo vs Rapture - Part 1

Image
Harpazo is different from rapture. Rapture is based on the notion that Christ comes with dead ones, picks up believers and makes a u turn and flies back up to heaven with unbelievers left behind.  It's helpful to consider Paul's word for "meeting" in this passage. It is the Greek word apantesis, which typically described the formal welcoming of a dignitary into a city. In other Greek literature, it was a term that described a great delegation that would travel to the outskirts of the city gates and beyond to receive the conquering king as he returned to the land." The Rapture counts for absurd eschatology.... And if you believe in the rapture guess who is taken? Not the righteous as you were taught but the wicked. Notice the disciples are asking "Where they were taken"... notice Christ's answer "wherever the dead bodies are for the vultures to consume" Luk 17:34 — Luk 17:37 I tell you, in that night there shall be two men in one bed; the o
Read more

Narrow Gate vs Broad Way

Image
That quote also comes from Luke 13... the ENTIRE Chapter is the context.. We can't just pull one verse to form a doctrine. This is the quote.. "Then one said to Him, “Lord, are there few who are saved?” And He said to them, 24 “ Strive to enter through the narrow gate, for many, I say to you, will seek to enter and will not be able" The question is saved from what?  is this talking about "eternal salvation"? NO.   Again context. Please make note of the following in Luke 13 The people who asked Christ this had little or no knowledge of the issues and particulars of salvation as we know it today. They were immediately reacting to Christ spreading an interesting message as he was heading towards Jerusalem. What was Christ's message? Well it started with folks pointing out that the Galileans were the most unfortunate because they had Pilate mix their blood with their sacrifices. They concluded that God judged them.  Doesn't that sound familiar with all the
Read more

Is Everything According to Gods Plan? Sovereign Will Part 1

Image
Questions: Why do we pray for God's will to be done if it is always done? What am I missing? Did he not know about it after all since the beginning? So if we deliberately don't do God's will, do we say, well he knew from the beginning that this will happen anyway? Why not? It's part of His Plan! There are many times God's will is not done. God's will, is and will always be done. Both statements are true? Do you agree or not? Answers: "Sovereign Will vs Permissive Will. God will permit us to do whatever we like, but eventually His Sovereign Will will be completed. Perfectly. No matter how well we play the game of Cosmic Chess against the Master of the Universe, He will win." - Andre van der Sandt "God's will is not done because man is flawed. Man makes wrong decisions sometimes when he uses his gift of free will. In which there is a lesson he will learn that will ultimately become God's will." - Ricky Diggs "His sovereign
Read more